Kevin Ahearn writes about...

The Gap Between “Us” and “Them”

Don:

New science fiction and fantasy sites created by “non-professionals” are premiering online almost every month to compete with dozens of online story sites that have been on the web for years.

Unfortunately, it is rare that any of the short stories, novels, or novelettes written by “non-professionals” ever gets a shred of respect from “professional” editors or writers. “If it’s on a non-paying site,” the “professionals” are quick to point out. “It can’t be worth anything.”

Of course, when a new “professional” site is set to come on, that’s altogether different!

Or is it?

“We believe in stories, short and long. For many popular authors, however, the low rates magazines pay for short stories have made writing them a tough economic choice. We're going to change that situation in the simplest way possible: by paying more,” reads the opening paragraph at BaensUniverse.com introducing Jim Baen’s new SF online magazine Universe. Sounds great if you’re a member of the Science Fiction Writers of America (SFWA) — a new high-paying market has opened up. But if one is a reader of science fiction searching for new, cutting-edge stuff?

“We promise to publish stories that keep you turning the (electronic) page, stories with characters and feeling similar to those of popular novels. Many of the stories, in fact, are set in universes already popular in novel form,” the blurb continues, psyching me up “to boldly go where no science fiction has gone before.”

For good reason. Jim Baen has published some landmark SF and even more important, has pioneered the marketing of SF on the Internet. And he’s offering free samples “to get me hooked.”

Eagerly I clicked my mouse and dug in for a treat! After reading the four first halves of stories to be posted in the June premier issue, it’s not that I was disappointed, but appalled ! Has Baen completely lost it?

One story was a “first-person whine” featuring a hip yuppie researching a computer game for a security company. I waited for an idea to show up, but none did. And that was the best of the bunch!

Second was a pseudo-Heinlein aping a war scene I’ve read a dozen times before in fiction and non-fiction.

Then came a mock Conan Doyle with a lame Sherlock Holmes wannabe narrated by a Dr. Watson stand-in.

Last and least was a “Martha Stewart of the future” skit nowhere near as interesting as the lady herself.

Time out. Just for a second. Yes, it’s very easy for me or anyone else to bash a new SF effort before it even gets off the ground. You may conclude that I am frustrated and biased against Baen, the SFWA or any particular writer. But Universe is about science fiction, the genre we love, and if this is where it’s going...

I can just imagine a writer interviewing for Universe, not unlike a stand-up comic auditioning for a TV spot, but instead of asking for new material giving a fresh slant on the 21st Century...

“How are your imitations?” I can hear Baen asking. “Do you do Asimov? How’s your Clarke? Can you do an early Steven King? We’re looking for safe, staid science fiction that won’t ruffle anybody’s feathers. You know, ‘science fiction by science fiction writers for science fiction fans’.”

And they want us to PAY for this! $30 a year! Right. They gotta be kidding! I can read all the second-class, pseudo “sci-fi” and yes, even some good stuff on the Net for FREE !

The proof is in the postings, SF fans. Is the “gap” closing? Or did it really ever exist? You tell me.

Kevin Ahearn

Thank you for the report, Kevin! We think it’s significant that you’ve brought it to Bewildering Stories, especially in light of what John Gilbert has to say about us at NeoSciFi.com. We wish Mr. Baen lots o’ luck. Meanwhile, we’re always on the lookout for “new material giving a fresh slant on the 21st century.” It’s precisely the sort of thing we dote on, and we think our readers and we have been very fortunate indeed.

Don